Fresh Fiction is thrilled to welcome historical fiction author Julia
Justiss for another installment of the History ReFreshed column. Austen
lovers--this one is for you!
Can’t get enough of Pride and Prejudice? Did PBS’s recent DEATH COMES TO PEMBERLEY whet your appetite for more, more,
ever more of your favorite characters and settings?
You’re not alone! There has been a prodigious profusion of fan-fiction books
embellishing the details and carrying on with the lives of the characters Jane
Austen so memorably created in her masterwork. So many, it will require several
columns to accommodate just the major works (many novella-length projects are
now available, especially in e-book format; only novel-length books will be
featured.)
We’ll begin with novels that have Darcy and Elizabeth as their main characters.
Why not start with the original of DEATH COMES TO
PEMBERLEY by P.D. James, and see just how closely the Masterpiece
adapters followed the plot line and characters of the novel. (I’m not
telling—you’ll have to read it for yourself!)
About: It is 1803, six years since Elizabeth and Darcy
embarked on their life together at Pemberley, Darcy’s magnificent estate. Their
peaceful, orderly world seems almost unassailable. Elizabeth has found her
footing as the chatelaine of the great house. They have two fine sons,
Fitzwilliam and Charles. Elizabeth’s sister Jane and her husband, Bingley, live
nearby; her father visits often; there is optimistic talk about the prospects of
marriage for Darcy’s sister Georgiana. And preparations are under way for their
much-anticipated annual autumn ball.
Then, on the eve of the ball, the patrician idyll is shattered. A coach careens
up the drive carrying Lydia, Elizabeth’s disgraced sister, who with her husband,
the very dubious Wickham, has been banned from Pemberley. She stumbles out of
the carriage, hysterical, shrieking that Wickham has been murdered. With
shocking suddenness, Pemberley is plunged into a frightening mystery.
P.D.
James’s stand-alone is rather rare; P&P adaptations are particularly
rich in series. Since everyone loves a good controversy, we’ll look first at
the Darcy Saga series by Sharon
Lathan. She’s become a best-selling author based on adaptations that
lean more toward the loosely-interpreted Keira Knightly movie version of the
classic. Readers tend to either love or loathe her work, with romance fiction
(and erotic romance fiction) fans doing the loving and Jane Austen
purists/historical fiction fans the loathing. Much of these stories,
particularly in the earlier books, involve long, frequent and graphic love
scenes between Darcy and Elizabeth. Are the novels trash or treasure? Perhaps
we should start a poll here at Fresh Fiction!
In chronological story, rather than publication order, we begin with:
(Darcy Saga Prequel Duo Part One; 2014)
This new prequel, (which contains episodes that were flashbacks in the first of
the Darcy Saga books, MR. AND MRS.
FITZWILLIAM DARCY) fills in the time period between Darcy’s proposal and the
wedding. Conflicts caused by Lady Catherine de Bourgh and Caroline Bingley, the
developing love between Jane and Charles Bingley, and the characters of the rest
of the Bennet family are more fully explored here.
MR. AND MRS. FITZWILLIAM DARCY: THE TWO SHALL BECOME ONE
(Darcy Saga; March 2009) The story begins
immediately after the wedding, and basically concerns the “Darcy honeymoon”
period, the bulk of the story consisting of the ardent young marrieds declaring
(and consummating again and again and again) their love.
(Darcy Saga; Sept 2009) The story
continues as Darcy and Elizabeth await the birth of their first child. More is
seen of their families and friends, with additional development in the
characters of Georgiana Darcy, Mary and Kitty Bennett and Caroline Bingley. As
with all the novels of this series, the focus is on the small everyday
interactions of life, rather than grand events, with a continuing copious
complement of love scenes between Darcy and his bride.
(Darcy Saga; Jan 2010) Now at the end of
their first year of marriage, Darcy and Elizabeth travel through the Lake
District and to the shore for some sea-bathing and sightseeing before the birth
of their first child. The inclusion of Dr. Darcy (who will later have his own
book,) the much-maligned Miss de Bourgh, news of Mary Bennet’s impending
marriage and the Bingleys’ upcoming addition to the family add new dimensions to
the saga.
(Darcy Saga; Oct 2010) The fourth book of
Lathan’s series begins a year after Darcy and Elizabeth’s wedding, and just
after the birth of their son Alexander. After Christmas with the whole Bennet
family at Pemberley, Elizabeth and Georgiana prepare to be presented at court,
Colonel Fitzwilliams rekindles an old romance, Kitty Bennet falls in love, and
Caroline Bingley encounters a fitting adversary.
(Darcy Saga; April 2011) The next
installment of the saga takes place a year later, with Elizabeth and Darcy now
the parents of two children. Returning to Netherfield for Kitty Bennett’s
marriage, they encounter George Wickham, now intent on creating trouble for
Lizzy and her young son. While Colonel Fitzwilliam steps in to help his friend
and cousin counter the villain, the character of Dr. Darcy, mentor and advisor
to his nephew, continues to be developed, and Georgianna returns from her tour,
ready for a romance of her own.
A second series with admirers and detesters split upon the same lines as
Lathan’s, which also catapulted its author into best-sellerdom, is penned by Linda
Berdoll.
MR DARCY TAKES A WIFE: PRIDE AND PREJUDICE CONTINUES
Originally self-published in 1999 as THE
BAR SINISTER, this first book of Berdoll’s series was later republished
under the new title by Sourcebooks in 2004. Like Lathan’s series, Berdoll’s work
excited heated debate. Booklist pronounced it “wild, bawdy and utterly
enjoyable,” while some readers found it a “respectful continuation” of Austen’s
work and others proclaimed it to be “so bad it’s unintentionally funny,” The
Austen-esque language, more convoluted than the original prose, trips up some
readers, while others decry the inclusion of numerous heated love scenes.
Definitely not for Austen purists, the book nonetheless charmed readers with its
more modern, realistic look at the Darcy marriage, and for its continuation of
the story of secondary characters such as Colonel Fitzwilliams, Wickham, Lydia,
and Lady Catherine--although Georgiana turns a bit feisty, and a secret from
Bingley’s past may shock.
The saga continues with Darcy returning from abroad
to greet his wife and new twins. Passion must be put on hold while Elizabeth
recovers, creating some tension, both Lydia and Wickham return to cause
mischief, and the imperious Lady Catherine meddles as only she can. Described by
Publishers Weekly as a “lighthearted romp” and Booklist as “a frothy historical
dessert following a meaty entrée of a classic,” those who enjoy the frequent
peeking into the bedchamber and the unusual prose will enjoy this sequel.
Berdoll’s latest installment picks up the story
nearly ten years into the Darcy marriage. Devotees of love scenes will be
reassured to discover the couple is no less amorous, though personal tragedy
drives them apart for a while; lovers of melodrama will be happy to see Wickham
once again attempting dastardly deeds; and a few of Berdoll’s own
characters—Lady Howgrave, Darcy’s former lover who tries to seduce him—carry the
story in different directions, with “traditional” Austen characters the Bingleys
and Bennets playing a lesser role.
Pining for another? Berdoll reports that volume four, working title MR.
DARCY TAKES HIS WIFE SOME MORE, is nearly finished. Check out her blog for updates.
Still thirsting for more? Never fear! Many other P&P works await, both
series and stand-alones. What Would Jane Say about all these
imitations of her work? This writer believes she’d be both amused and
affronted!