Hannah was a normal girl starting in her first year of college. Her boyfriend Evan begs her to come with him to a party at one of the fraternities. Hannah really didn't want to go, but it was the only way Evan could get in. Little did they both know that this would change both of their lives and several others...

Fast forward about 20 years. Hannah and Evan are now married, but far from being happy. Hannah is still having nightmares of what happened that night at the party. Hannah was assaulted by several football players. Hannah can't handle it anymore and on Christmas Eve she jumps into an icy river and dies.

Meanwhile one of Hannah's assaulters, former quarterback Josh Thorne is enjoying his life as a Wall Street millionaire, with his wife Rachael. Charlie is also enjoying his life with his wife and children. One night Josh is out at a bar and approaches a woman named Norah. Josh has never been faithful to his wife has no problem going with this woman for a quickie... until he's found savagely murdered. Soon after this, another attacker is also found dead after being brutalized.

Detectives Mike McCabe and Maggie Savage are on the case, trying to stop more of these unfortunately related murders keep happening to Hannah's attackers from 20 years ago.