OH, FUDGE! is book five in Nancy Coco's Candy-Coated cozy mystery series featuring hotelier and fudge maker Allie McMurphy. Although this book is part of a series, readers new to the series should still be able to enjoy OH, FUDGE!. This book includes a family feud that Allie didn't even know she was involved in. Allie had no idea her cousin Tori was a little miffed that Allie solely inherited the McMurphy hotel and fudge shop. This newly discovered polite animosity makes trying to clear Tori from suspicion of murder a little difficult. It doesn't help that Tori was found at the murder scene, covered in blood, and clutching the murder weapon. Butterflies and burglaries play a part in the tangled murder mystery that Allie tries to unravel.

Barbara Smart is a nightmare of a homicide victim for investigators because so many people had a motive for wanting her dead. The risk to Allie gets progressively worse as she discovers more about the victim and asks probing questions. Allie persists even when the police and her cousin tell her to back off. There are numerous brainteasers in OH, FUDGE! for readers to try to wrap their minds around. Allie and the police investigating the murder are thrown a bit off balance because this mystery could have multiple villains working separately or together. Things get even more personal for Allie when her love life works its way into her investigation.

OH, FUDGE! is full of suspense and surprises, with fun friendships to ease the tension. Nancy Coco details the bias consistent with insular communities such as Mackinac Island. No matter how rooted she is to the island, Allie is still considered a "Fudgie" versus a true islander. Through everything, Allie has her loyal dog Mal, BFF Jenn, intrepid reporter Liz McElroy, and the bride and groom-to-be Frances and Mr. Devaney for support and to assist in her sleuthing. As a romance fan, I can't wait to see what twists Allie's love life takes in future stories. I look forward to the next Candy-Coated mystery by Nancy Coco.