It all started with the arrival of a book....

Simon Watson is barely staying afloat, living in his family's home that is getting closer and closer to falling into the Long Island Sound. A surprise package arrives in the mail and sends Simon on a research quest to discover more about his heritage. What secrets are hidden within the water damaged book detailing the events of a traveling carnival? Is the past about to repeat itself?

THE BOOK OF SPECULATION alternates between the past and the present, as readers are drawn into the daily lives of carnival performers in the 1700s. Erika Swyler does a great job at pulling together the two time periods to show readers a fascinating portrait of the effects of a family curse. I love the slow, meandering pace as we get to savor the intricacies of the relationships. I especially love how Amos learns to communicate despite his inability to verbally speak.

The secondary characters in THE BOOK OF SPECULATION fascinate me and I wish we had gotten to know a bit more of their history. Doyle, in particular, has such a story to tell. Instead, we spent far too much time with Simon and I couldn't help but wonder what Alice saw in him that was attractive. THE BOOK OF SPECULATION would have been one of my favorite reads of the year had I liked Simon even just a little bit as the story itself is enchanting.

THE BOOK OF SPECULATION is a dark and haunting tale of the lasting impacts of history on a family. Erika Swyler's splendid storytelling draws the reader into the world of a traveling carnival. THE BOOK OF SPECULATION is a stunning debut novel and I look forward to reading more by Erika Swyler in the future.