October 16th, 2026
Home | Log in!
❤ ❤ ❤ ❤ ❤
Welcome to FreshFiction

Are you a reader
or an author?

Help us personalize your experience. Choose your role below.
You can always change this later using the switcher button.

or

You can switch anytime using the floating button.

Limited Time Fresh Fiction Access

Exclusive Marketing Opportunities for Authors

Curious about how Fresh Access helps authors gain more visibility and connect with active readers?

Discover premium promotional opportunities, enhanced exposure, and author-focused services designed to help your books stand out.

Read More →
Fresh Pick
THE RALLY
📚 New Books This Week 📰 Latest News 🎪 Reader Games 👻 🎃 Halloween Contest Giveaways 🎃

October Reads Worth Falling For

Danger, desire, second chances, and unexpected romanceβ€”discover this month’s Fresh Fiction Featured Books.

Slideshow image


slideshow image
A poisoned cousin, a five-year-old's life, and a family with too many secrets.


slideshow image
Supernatural sparks fly
between a bookseller
& her hard-boiled ghost.


slideshow image
If Her Highness thinks I’ll let another man claim her and my child, she’s lost her royal mind. Sophaya’s mine.


slideshow image
She found a body. Then she started asking the wrong questions.


slideshow image
He ghosted her ten years ago. Now she’s stuck with him for Christmas.


slideshow image
She’s the lady everyone overlooks. He’s the prince who can’t look away.

CAROLINE'S SECRET

Caroline's Secret, August 2014
Wells Landing
by Amy Lillard

Kensington Zebra
Featuring: Caroline Hostetler; Andrew Fitch
384 pages
ISBN: 1420134531
EAN: 9781420134537
Kindle: B00IKOTSF6
Mass Market Paperback / e-Book
Add to Wish List

Purchase

"To Move Forward, You Have To Let Go Of The Past"

Fresh Fiction Review

CAROLINE'S SECRET
Amy Lillard

Reviewed by Susan Dyer
Posted August 9, 2014

Inspirational Amish

Caroline has a secret and it is a huge one! She is an Amish woman living in Oklahoma with a very small child. Everyone assumes she is a widow, but that isnt the truth and she does not correct them. CAROLINE'S SECRET by Amy Lillard isn't your typical Amish novel. It touches on a subject you don't usually read about with the Amish people. I was instantly caught up in Caroline's life and found myself holding my breath at some parts of CAROLINE'S SECRET.

Caroline was on a bus from Tennessee to Colorado when she got sick and got off in Oklahoma. A nice woman, Esther, took her in and gave her a job. Esther never asks questions about Caroline's past and she just assumes that her husband passed away. This is where her secret comes in but I am not telling you what it is. Believe me, in the Amish world it is a huge one.

Caroline makes friends with Andrew, an Amish man who is helping out his uncle Abe at his furniture store. Andrew was in love with a woman named Beth who was sick and passed away. Andrew is still struggling with his loss when he meets Caroline. Neither one of them is looking for a relationship any further than friends. At least that is what they tell themselves.

While Andrew and Caroline are trying to sort out their lives, Esther and Abe are finally admitting to each other that they both have had feelings for the other for a long long time. Esther and Abe are hysterical and the things they say to each other will have you laughing out loud. Esther has been alone since her husband died years ago and Abe wonders if she is really ready to move on.

I found myself thinking about Andrew and Caroline long after I finished their story. I was totally invested in their lives and was cheering for them the whole time I was reading. CAROLINE'S SECRET is my first time reading Amy Lillard but I can tell you it wont be the last. As an added bonus there are recipes in the back and who doesn't love that?

CAROLINE'S SECRET is filled with love, forgiveness, letting go, and romance. Once I started reading, I couldn't stop. Amy's writing held me captive from the very first page until the last page. Courting Emily will be published in January 2015 and that will be the second book in this series.

Learn more about CAROLINE'S SECRET

SUMMARY

In Amy Lillard's poignant introduction to Wells Landing, a small Amish community is home to two brave souls hoping to forget their painful pasts and rebuild their faith in the future. . . Caroline Hostetler arrived in Oklahoma determined to forge a new life for herself and her daughter, Emma. As a single mother, she values the warmth and safety she's found in close-knit Wells Landing. She's even caught the eye of a handsome newcomer--a man who just may be the partner she longs for and the father Emma deserves. But the arrival of an Englisher threatens to lay bare the secrets she's worked so hard to leave behind. . . After losing his life-long sweetheart, Andrew Fitch moved to Wells Landing to work in his uncle's furniture business and nurse his broken heart. Finding love again seems all but impossible--until he meets Caroline and Emma. But his plans to join their lives together may be shattered when the truth of Caroline's past comes to light--unless, together, they can learn the true meaning of sacrifice and forgiveness. . .

EXCERPT

No excerpt available.

BOOK SERIES

Wells Landing

Caroline's Secret
CAROLINE'S SECRET
#1.0 β€’ August 2014
Courting Emily
COURTING EMILY
#2.0 β€’ January 2015
Lorie's Heart
LORIE'S HEART
#3.0 β€’ August 2015
Just Plain Sadie
JUST PLAIN SADIE
#4.0 β€’ April 2016
Titus Returns
TITUS RETURNS
#5.0 β€’ January 2017
Marrying Jonah
MARRYING JONAH
#6.0 β€’ April 2017
A New Love for Charlotte
A NEW LOVE FOR CHARLOTTE
#11.0 β€’ April 2021