In 1925, a series of earthquakes tore through Manhattan leaving half the city under water. Fifty years later, fourteen-year-old Molly McHugh lives in the dark, watery city, and her friend and boss, Felix Orlov, an aging magician, is abducted by strange mask wearing, rubber-suited beings. Molly escapes and seeks help from investigator Simon Church and his mysterious assistant, Joe Golem. Simon and Joe must stop evil Dr. Cocteau and his dubious plan.

I was excited to hear of another Mignola/Golden collaboration. Fans of their work will undoubtedly understand. Christopher Golden and Mike Mignola do a great job of weaving a tale of mystery, intrigue and suspense. Lovers of steampunk and horror will enjoy the respective elements of both, be they the unsaid horrors that are left to the imagination or Mr. Church's mechanical body organs.

I really enjoyed the element of the golem and how Joe was a more human portrayal than I'm used to reading. He was a fully fleshed out (pardon the pun) character who had his own past to deal with. Simon's Sherlock Holmes persona was pulled off with aplomb and enough distance to be his own.

Molly is a delightful character, strong to be so young, and described so that I could see her in detail. I would be hard pressed to pick a favorite.

This tale is of the YA genre, so it reads accordingly, ie a fourteen year old protagonist. No hardcore horror here, but it was adequate and still sated this horror lovers' thirst. I particularly love the Lovecraft feel. My only complaint... I would've loved to have seen more drawings from the artist, Mike Mignola, of Hellboy fame, but this is why JOE GOLEM AND THE DROWNING CITY is classified as an illustrated novel and not a graphic novel, so it's to be expected. Fans of fiction and graphic novels, urban fantasy and horror, will hopefully unite with this fantastical tale.