While on the surface A.J. Scudiere's GOD'S EYE is a story in which one woman, Katharine Geryon, must choose between two men, one being an angel and the other a demon, at the heart it is a tale about the choices we make and the results. Daughter of the owner of a wealthy investment enterprise, Katharine has worked tirelessly at her father's company, learning the ins and outs to the empire that will one day be passed down to her. She has always done the right thing, rarely veering off this path. Most of the workers resent her, seeing her as rich and aloof. Then two gorgeous men come into her life, one a next-door neighbor and the other, her new assistant. Both want to utterly charm her and win her, but what she doesn't realize at first is that one is an angel and the other a demon. A friendship with Margot, a librarian, helps her figure out their motives, but nothing can help her figure out which is which and help her to make the right choices or if there is a right choice at all.

Scudiere's novel shows us there are consequences to all of our choices, good or bad, recognized or unrecognized. At first, Katharine had unconsciously made choices, but they still had repercussions. So as she struggles to figure out the motives of Zachary and Alistair and comes to terms with the strange appearances of soot and strange animals in her apartment, she begins to understand that if she's making choices anyway, it is best to understand them.

GOD'S EYE has a great storyline, but I do have a couple issues. Katharine becomes involved with both men and while I understand that this is part of the plot in which they both wish to win her heart, I have issues with infidelity on any level. Also, I figured out which man was which fairly early on. That said, it was still interesting to see what Katharine does and how she makes her final decision. Given my two quibbles, I still liked the ending, and it certainly wasn't what I expected. Fans of paranormal romance and psychological thrillers will likely enjoy this story.