Prologue
โFive minutes!โ
The gnome in the radio headset raised a hairy little hand
with all five digits splayed, in case weโd failed to hear
him shouting at us in our earpiece microphones. As I
reached to adjust mine โ it felt like Iโd fallen asleep
at my computer and awoken with the mouse lodged in my ear
โ Terina Webb, our panel moderator, gently took my arm.
โQuit fidgeting.โ
โWhat?โ
โI said, stop fidgeting. You act like youโve never done
this before.โ
โI told you Iโve never done this before.โ
โI know,โ she said, โbut donโt act like it. I told my
producer you were a pro.โ
We were seated at a raised horseshoe podium, its surface
gleaming Lucite, its swivel chairs done in chrome and
black calfskin leather. Behind us, a curving video
screen carried a live feed from the civil courthouse in
Van Nuys, California, where Day One of this yearโs Trial
of the Century had just recessed for lunch. Arrayed
before us were four TV monitors on which weโd been
following the morningโs proceedings from the relative
comfort of the cavernous CBS News soundstage in Studio
City, less than ten miles from the courthouse.
At the other end of the horseshoe, presently engrossed in
whispered conversation, sat a pair of tassel-loafered
Beverly Hills divorce lawyers who, had they been on the
meter, would have been billing Channel Nine Action News a
combined five grand per hour. Today, however, they โ
along with yours truly โ had been dragooned into
providing expert trial commentary for the over five
million Southern California housewives, shut-ins, and
unemployed actors with nothing better to do on a hazy
Monday in June than curl up with some popcorn and pray
for the second coming of O.J.
โFour minutes!โ
The trial in progress was a so-called palimony action
brought by Rosemary โRandiโ Tandy, a former adult-film
actress, against the widow of legendary Hollywood media
mogul Lew Rothstein. Mrs. Rothstein โ Betsy to her
friends โ was the executor of Big Lewโs billion-dollar
estate. She was also, it seems, the last of her gilded
social circle to learn that her octogenarian husband had
โ according to the now-undisputed DNA evidence โ fathered
three teenage daughters with the erstwhile thespian.
One can safely assume that most forty-something starlets
whose career apogee was a bachelor-party standard called
Randi Does Richmond would have been content, if faced
with the same situation, to sign a confidentiality
agreement and receive a quiet million dollars in child
support from the Rothstein estate. But then, most porn
stars would have lacked the perspicacity to hire Maxine
Cameron โ the Pit Bull in Prada โ as their lawyer. Just
as most lawyers would have lacked the requisite something
โ letโs call them clanking brass balls โ to sue for half
the Rothstein fortune on the enterprising theory that Big
Lew had verbally promised as much to his blushing young
paramour.
โThree minutes!โ
Since jury selection and opening statements had concluded
last week, the morningโs televised proceedings had begun
with Maxine Cameronโs direct examination of her client.
Ms. Tandy had dressed for this solemn occasion in
leopard-print spandex with matching high heels, and sheโd
teetered to the witness stand with a Kleenex box in her
bejeweled hand โ always a harbinger of good television to
come. Sheโd then, under her counselโs machine-gun
questioning, described with the exactitude of an Army
quartermaster every gift, trifle, and bauble Big Lew had
lavished upon her during their twenty-plus years of
quasi-connubial bliss.
It was an impressive inventory that ranged from furs to
diamonds to six Mercedes-Benz automobiles.
โTwo minutes!โ
Once Big Lewโs generosity had been firmly established,
the plaintiff next chronicled for the jury the many
exotic vacations the couple had taken together, from Maui
to Gstaad, Lake Como to Phuket Island. I was running a
tape in my head, and by the time the judge had called the
noon recess, Iโd put the total of Big Lewโs largesse at
around six and a half million dollars.
My telephone vibrated, earning scowls both from Terina
and the gnome in the headset.
โTalk to me.โ
โI just left the clerkโs office downtown.โ Regan Fife,
my office investigator, had to shout to be heard over the
rumble of L.A. street traffic.
โAnd?โ
โAnd you were right,โ she said. โThereโs nothing in the
file.โ
โOkay, thanks.โ
I powered down the phone and slipped it into my pocket.
By now the makeup girl had reappeared on set and was
moving down the line with her little powder-puff thingy.
โOne minute!โ
Terina shoved back from the podium, the better to deliver
a final pep-talk to her trio of expert panelists.
โOkay, listen up. Iโll do a short intro, then turn it
over to you. Weโll go from stage right to left, starting
with Marv. Just touch on what you thought were the
morningโs highlights, and then weโll go to commercial.
Ten minutes total. That means youโll each have up to
three minutes to talk.โ To me she added, โRemember to
look into the camera with the red light showing. And
stop doing that thing with your ear.โ
Marvin Broadman, the most famous divorce attorney in all
of Beverly Hills โ a town with more family lawyers than
parking meters โ cleared his throat as he smiled into
Camera Two.
โTen seconds!โ
A pharmaceutical commercial was running silently on the
monitors โ floating butterflies carried a harried young
housewife to bed after a day of domestic drudgery โ when
the light blinked red on Camera One, and the video feed
cut to Terina Webb in medium close-up.
โWelcome back to Channel Nine Action Newsโ live and in-
depth coverage of the blockbuster Beverly Hills Bigamy
Trial. Iโm Terina Webb, your studio host, and Iโm joined
today by three of the biggest names in the L.A. legal
world: Marvin Broadman, Tom Schwartz, and Jack
MacTaggart.โ Terina did a half-turn to her right.
โWeโll start with you, Marv. First impressions, what did
you think of what you heard in court this morning?โ
On the monitor, superimposed beneath Broadmanโs grinning
yap, were his name and the tag-line Divorce Lawyer to the
Stars.
โWell, Terina, you know that whenever you have Maxine
Cameron in a courtroom, youโre going to see fireworks,
and today was certainly no exception. She effectively
established three things right up front that are critical
to her theory of the case. First, that the relationship
between her client and Lew Rothstein was a close one.
Second, that Big Lewโs generosity toward Ms. Tandy knew
no bounds. And third, that they traveled the world
together, often holding themselves out to the public as
husband and wife. It remains to be seen whether Maxine
can make the leap from those key facts to proving a
promise to leave half the Rothstein estate to Ms. Tandy,
but I think sheโs off to a heck of a good start. And
given her track record with juries, I wouldnโt want to be
betting against her.โ
โTom?โ
A decade younger than Broadman, Schwartz had leading-man
looks and a Faustian reputation as the go-to guy in
Hollywood for challenging prenuptial agreements. He was
said to have every tabloid and gossip-rag editor in the
country on speed-dial. He was also rumored to be on
monthly retainer by the Celebrity Centre of the Church of
Scientology.
โIโd have to concur with my friend on all counts, Terina.
Weโve both litigated against Maxine Cameron, and Iโm sure
Marv will agree that when Maxine takes on a clientโs
cause, she makes it personal. She also has an uncanny
knack for proving what might, at first blush, seem highly
improbable. We saw that this morning with her opening
gambit of establishing the kind of close relationship
between Ms. Tandy and Lew Rothstein that could easily
have led to the promise weโll soon be hearing about. Iโd
look for more of the same this afternoon, ending with a
bombshell at around four-thirty that will jolt the jury
awake and send them home with an entirely different view
of her client and her clientโs case.โ
Terina squared some papers as she swiveled to my side of
the podium.
โJack?โ
The light on Camera Three blinked red, and I stared into
the lens. I was, Iโll admit, at a momentary loss for
words, given that Schwartz and Broadman โ both supremely
confident in their analyses โ were reputedly among the
best in their specialized field.
โSay something!โ barked the headset gnome, his klaxon
voice echoing deep in my cochlear canal.
I cleared my throat and swallowed.
โI guess I have a slightly different take on Ms.
Cameronโs performance this morning than do my esteemed
colleagues.โ I glanced down the podium at Broadman and
Schwartz, both of whom were frowning back at me. โIโm
not a family lawyer, but I did do a bit of research
before I came down here today, and one thing I noted is
that the California Family Code gives an innocent spouse
up to three years from date of discovery within which to
recover for the community estate any unauthorized gifts
made by the other spouse during the marriage. Also, I
had my investigator check the probate file downtown, and
it appears that there was never a creditorโs claim filed
by Ms. Tandy against the Rothstein estate within the
four-month statutory deadline.โ
Terinaโs brow had furrowed. โThe significance of all
that being . . .?โ
โThat unless Iโm mistaken, Maxine Cameron just proved up
an airtight reimbursement case against her own client,
under oath, to the tune of around seven million dollars.
And if she never filed a written claim in the probate
action, then Iโd say her palimony case against the
Rothstein estate is dead in the water, barred by
limitations.โ
Silence fell over the set. Schwartz and Broadman shared
a glance, with Broadman muttering something that sounded
like โHoly shit.โ
Terina, herself at an uncharacteristic loss for words,
swiveled back to the camera.
โUh, why donโt we come back to explore these fascinating
new developments after a quick word from our sponsors.โ
My nascent career in punditry proved, alas, to be short-
lived, since the first day of the blockbuster Beverly
Hills Bigamy Trial was also the last. Betsy Rothsteinโs
motion for a directed verdict was granted after the first
dayโs lunch recess had ended and, a week later, the
Rothstein estate sued Randi Tandy to recover some eight
million dollars in luxury goods and services. Which, in
the finest American tradition, Ms. Tandy sought to recoup
by filing a legal malpractice action against her lawyer,
Maxine Cameron.
On the whole, it promised to be another banner year for
the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
But the affair was not without a silver lining, as,
perhaps ten days after my appearance on television, the
phone rang in the law offices of MacTaggart & Suarez, and
an elderly gentleman introduced himself as a friend of
Betsy Rothstein. He asked, in a courtly French accent,
whether Iโd be willing to consult with him on a matter
that was, as he put it, of โsome delicacy.โ
When he offered to pay for the consultation, travel time
included, I was favorably disposed toward his request.
Then, when he offered to send his private jet to fetch me
up for a weekend in Napa Valley, I had no choice but to
agree.
Chuck Greaves is the award-winning author of HUSH MONEY,
GREEN-EYED LADY, and THE LAST HEIR, all from St. Martinโs
Minotaur. Writing as C. Joseph Greaves, he is the author
of HARD TWISTED and the forthcoming TOM & CHARLIE (AND
GEORGE & COKEY FLO), both from Bloomsbury.