May 7th, 2021
Home | Log in!

Fresh Pick

New Books This Week

Latest Articles


Reviewer Application

Books to enjoy in May! Let your reading blosson!

Slideshow image

Since your web browser does not support JavaScript, here is a non-JavaScript version of the image slideshow:

slideshow image
A prim bookseller and her hardboiled ghost team up to catch a cunning killer inů

slideshow image
Welcome to Bushwhack, New Mexico: home to tourists, the great outdoors, and murderů

slideshow image
Friendship. Second chances. Lots of dogs!

slideshow image
A secret no one dared whisper...

slideshow image
In service to His Majesty, one must be prepared for Hell.

slideshow image

Butter Safe Than Sorry

Butter Safe Than Sorry, February 2010
A Pennsylvania Dutch Mystery #17
by Tamar Myers

NAL Trade
272 pages
ISBN: 045122910X
EAN: 9780451229106
Add to Wish List


"Perhaps Butter Left Alone...Buttery mystery just doesn't set well!"

Fresh Fiction Review

Butter Safe Than Sorry
Tamar Myers

Reviewed by Sharon Galligar Chance
Posted March 29, 2010

Mystery Cozy

I want to begin this review by saying that I am coming into this series at the 17th book, so I am unfamiliar with a lot of the backstory. That being said...

BUTTER SAFE THAN SORRY finds the Amish-turned-Mennonite-innkeeper Magdalena Yoder embroiled in yet another stewpot of trouble with all the ingredients for high adventure. Magdalena and her young son, Jacob, are at the bank when a trio of masked "Amish" men burst in to rob the place. When inquisitive Jacob sets off to find out who the men are, Magdalena throws herself on her boy to save him, only to skid right into the robbers, causing them to shoot one of the tellers in the arm. The robbers flee but not before arousing Magdalena's suspicions.

After resting a while at her mother-in-law's Sisters of Perpetual Apathy convent, Magdalena is back on her feet and up to her ears with quirky guests, a murder investigation or two, a incarcerated sister, and a brother-in-law with a vendetta. Not to mention her poor befuddled husband, the handsome Jewish Dr. Gabe.

As the seventeenth book in the series, BUTTER SAFE THAN SORRY seems to be a well intentioned story that somehow lost it's way. The reader is left with the feeling of being left out of a joke or two, and the storyline ends up as just a string of disjointed inside jokes that I'm sure fans of the series understand and find hilarious, But for the rest of the reading world, we are a bit mystified.

There are some lovely butter-influenced recipes included among the chapters, but they almost seem an afterthought, and for some reason all come from

This is just a guess, but perhaps author Tamar Myers is wrapping up this series, as the epilogue seems to tidy up a lot of loose ends for the characters. I'm sure her fans will be sorry to see the end of the spunky Magdalena.

Learn more about Butter Safe Than Sorry


From the national bestselling author of Batter Off Dead, the newest Pennsylvania Dutch mystery!

Mennonite innkeeper Magdalena Yoder is at the bank with her four-year- old son when three armed Amish men burst in and start shooting and-more surprisingly- cursing. Magdalena protects Little Jacob, and the robbers flee at the sound of police sirens.

When Jacob wonders why the bandits had mustaches-unlike all the other Amish men he knows-Magdalena springs into action to catch the thieves. They may be armed, but they may not be Amish!

What do you think about this review?


No comments posted.

Registered users may leave comments.
Log in or register now!




© 2003-2021  all rights reserved Privacy Policy