Ouray, Colorado
Friday Memorial Day Weekend
THE DISORIENTATION WAS BACK. Well, not back. It had never
left, simply became worse when any loud sound intruded on
her world. And music — music was not the same. Sophie
could hardly bear to listen now or try to sing because it
terrified her. It terrified her that crystal clear had
changed to an underwater-like whining, to distortion, to
an unsilence that made one ear worse than useless,
disallowing enjoyment of the other's perfection.
A virus had done it, a virus others had caught as well,
but it hadn't wrecked their ears. The doctors had said her
hearing might improve with time, that many people did
eventually get better on their own.
Two long courses of prednisone that had kept her
insomniac, alternately terrified that her gift was lost
and manically convinced that her genius, like Beethoven's,
could transcend this. Months of oxygen therapy. Acu-
puncture. Sessions with a Lakota medicine man and then
with a shaman from the Andes. Anything, anything, to help.
One perfect ear, and one ear with severe hearing loss and
twelve percent speech discrimination. She'd nearly been
hit by cars twice — or would have been. But the dogs both
knew. Somehow they knew, and Cinders had shoved herself
between the car and Sophie, pushing her mistress clear,
while a car horn blared, painful, making the world rock.
Loki had developed the habit, suddenly, of crowding
Sophie's left thigh, as though anticipating the kind of
trouble Cinders had averted.
Sophie had come back to Ouray, telling herself there were
fewer cars here and less noise. She'd stay at her parents'
summer place, the home they'd bought long ago for a
retirement that had finally arrived. Sophie had brought
her own home, too, her custom-built wayfaring wagon,
styled after an English gypsy wagon — for when her parents
arrived in June, just in case. Just in case they drove her
crazy — and the reverse, of course. Ouray seemed unchanged
from when she'd visited for three weeks each summer
growing up.
It was summer now. The mountains were steadfast, rising
steeply on each side of town, charming Victorian homes
nestled at the valley's narrow head. And there were plenty
of cars, not a parking space to be found on Main Street,
definitely not for a rig like hers, a truck hauling a
gypsy wagon.
And there was too much noise.
What if it doesn't get better? What if I always hear like
this?
Braking the Tundra for some tourists trying to cross Main
Street, she glanced behind her at Loki, front paws hanging
over the back seat of the dual cab, dark brown eyes
intelligent and concerned. Cinders had the bed on the
floor behind the passenger seat.
I'll still have my dogs.
She laughed, half-hysterically.
After everything. After backbreaking work, after
sacrifices — one sacrifice too keen to be counted — after
fighting and winning, was she now to lose it all?
So — back to the scene of the crime. Back here again. It
had happened long ago, but she would never stop thinking
about it, never stop remembering, never stop wondering
what her life would have been like, where that child,
fourteen this summer, was now.
Sophie Creed, thirty-two, was attractive — some said
beautiful — successful and talented, a musician whose
hearing was suddenly compromised.
She should go to the market before she arrived at the
house. She could have gotten groceries in Mont-rose but
hadn't wanted to face a big store. It wasn't that she'd be
recognized. That seldom happened. It was just the sound —
the noise. The doctors had said she'd become accustomed.
Sophie didn't want to get used to it. She wanted her
hearing back.
She sang. Every day she still sang. And danced. And played
the harmonica and her violin. Bearing it. But music
brought tears because sound that had been clear and
perfect was now distorted.
She had passed the market when she saw a delivery truck
leaving a place on the right, on the lower side, the west
side, of the wide, sharply tilted street. Surely she could
pull over there for long enough to run into the store.
Sophie switched on her turn signal, waited, parked
carefully along the curb. She'd put the dogs in the truck
bed. They'd be happier waiting there.
Someone had told her she could train one or both of them
as hearing dogs. As far as Sophie was concerned, they'd
already begun that job, were already doing it. Both knew.
Loki, the sable shepherd she'd gotten from the humane
society, seemed to realize her plight. But Cinders, a long-
haired sable she'd bought three years earlier from a
breeder whose grail was Westminster — Cinders acted.
As she loaded them into the back of the truck, Sophie
admired their muscles, their lustrous coats, the tall set
of their ears. Sound roared in her own ears, and she
jumped as a car passed. The cacophony in her bad left ear
was so overwhelming that she couldn't, in that moment,
hear properly out of her right. And she couldn't hear
where the sound had originated, had no directional
orientation.
She jumped when she saw someone just beside her. "Sorry,"
the girl apologized. She was a young teenager, dark-
haired, with very fair skin, a few freckles, glasses and
braces. "I just...your dogs."
Sophie said, "What?" Another car passed, and she
started. "I'm sorry. I have a hearing problem right now."
She'd had it for five months. Some people got better; some
didn't. A hearing aid wouldn't help but would only make it
more difficult to hear from her good ear. Plugging the
left ear didn't really help, either.
And that was for normal functioning.
But she was a musician. "Your dogs are beautiful. I wanted
to see them. My dad...dogs."
"You can pet them." Sophie tried not to jump as another
vehicle passed.
The girl offered a closed hand to Cinders for the bitch to
sniff. Loki hung back, reserved. His appearance was
obviously European — blocky-headed, sturdy, powerful,
extraordinarily male. He and Cinders looked like two
different breeds, beautiful in different ways. Cinders had
good hips. Loki's were fair.
Sophie studied the girl. She had excellent posture, seemed
self-possessed, with some regal characteristic beyond
dignity that acknowledged neither nearsightedness nor
braces. Her hair shone smooth, almost black with just a
hint of dark red. Behind her glasses, her eyes were brown.
Her coloring was not unlike Sophie's, fair, with a good
complexion.
And Sophie, tired of contact lens problems at gigs, had
undergone laser surgery on her eyes four years before. "Do
you live here?" she asked, to be polite. An eighteen-
wheeler, down off Red Mountain Pass, rumbled by, and
Sophie tried not to cringe. I have to get away from this
noise.
The girl nodded. "We train protection...I said. Also bomb,
drug...that kind of thing. Mostly...obedience now.
Aggression problems. My dad used to be... Then he..."
No hesitation in the words, but Sophie's hearing missed
some. She watched the teenager's lips, collecting and
failing to collect information. "Did you grow up here?"
Not caring, being polite.
"We lived in Denver...eight. Then, my dad...retired...K-
9... But he grew up here — well, kind of. His parents
helped raise me. My mom died when I was a baby."
The skin on the back of Sophie's neck hummed, electric,
her whole body sharply aware. She knew. Not in words. In
her bones. She didn't yet know what she knew, but every
part of her was knowledge. "Who is your father?"
"William Ludlow. I'm Amy."
That was what she knew. The other thing she knew, seeing
the girl's brown eyes that were the same shape as her own,
with the same slightly lush, slightly curling, sable
lashes, was that Amy Ludlow's mother had not died when Amy
was a baby.
Amy's mother was Sophie Creed.
DEAD?
That had not been part of the agreement, the solemn
agreement she'd made with William Ludlow not long after
her eighteenth birthday. It seemed unlikely to her, almost
unbelievable, that skinny black-haired William Ludlow with
his clear brown eyes, with his heavy black brows, had
become a cop. He had been a writer; his interests were
languages and math. He'd been to school all over the
world, spent time in Papua New Guinea, Indonesia, Irian
Jaya, places like that. His father was an ethnolinguist,
specializing in the languages of New Guinea. When Sophie
met William, he'd been familiar with seven or eight
languages (three of them dead) besides English, plus some
tribal dialects absolutely useless unless one were to
travel to these places, where people practiced customs
Sophie had found both horrifying and fascinating. And he'd
had a plan. Whenever anyone asked him what he was going to
be, his answer was always the same. An ethnologist and
author.
He'd wanted to study other cultures, whether Hasidic Jews
in New York or indigenous peoples of the Arctic.
How could he have become a cop?
She hadn't asked Amy.
He'd chosen their daughter's name, and Sophie hadn't
argued, hadn't much cared.
William had told Amy that her natural mother was dead.
No. That was not part of the agreement.
Pulling the truck and wagon to the curb outside her
parents' four-square Victorian, Sophie tried to shrug it
off. What, after all, had she expected of him? Her father
was a minister — her parents' life was about God — but
when she'd revealed that she was pregnant, William had
become even more traditional than she was. He'd mentioned —
once — her abandoning Amy, which had rubbed Sophie more
than a little wrong. She'd been adopted herself, had never
believed herself abandoned and never felt a burning desire
to look for her birth parents. Besides, William's parents
were going to help him with the baby.
But next her status as an adopted child slash birth mother
had come up for review. William had suggested — again,
only once — that she'd felt compelled to give up Amy to
justify her own birth mother's having relinquished her.
Sophie hadn't told Amy her name. But Amy had said where to
find Mount Sneffels K-9. The property was off the Camp
Bird road, on the way up to Yankee Boy Basin, she'd said.
We breed them, too, but we don't have any litters right
now. So many people are bringing dogs for us to train. We
have German shepherds, though, and Dutch shepherds, and a
Dogue de Bordeaux. Our German shepherds come from
Czechoslavakia, and one of our studs is a black sable.
Your dark sable reminds me of him.
Or so Sophie thought she'd said.
Would she take Amy up on her invitation to visit Mount
Sneffels K-9?
Ever since she'd relinquished her infant daughter, walked
away from her for reasons of foresight and maturity, she'd
known that if she really wanted, she could find William
Ludlow and contact him again and meet the daughter she'd
let go. But she'd never planned to do it. She'd planned
not to contact Amy.
Amy had been born in Glenwood Springs. During her
pregnancy, Sophie had lived in nearby Carbondale with
William. She hadn't wanted the people of Ouray to know she
was pregnant. If they didn't know, they couldn't tell the
child the identity of her birth mother.
Later she'd typed up something for William to give Amy, a
description of herself, of her health issues as she knew
them, of her talents and dreams. That, she had reasoned,
would allow Amy to develop a healthy identity.
Had William even shared the information she'd left for
their daughter?
She trembled in the afternoon shadows — shade cast by the
mountains that clutched the town. She unloaded the dogs
and took them up to the house, unlocked the door.
Did her parents know? William and Amy had obviously been
in Ouray for some time. Wasn't it likely that her parents
had run into one or both of them? And they'd always liked
William, despite their disapproval of sexual activity
outside marriage.
Sophie loved the Ouray house. On her brief, infrequent
trips to Ouray since leaving home, she had helped her
parents with what she called the house's "salvage style."
Even the front door, with its Arts and Crafts stained
glass, had been rescued from a condemned building in Salt
Lake City. Sophie had come across the door during some
rare downtime on tour. And in the foyer sat two Gothic
Revival chairs she and her mother had refinished and
reupholstered, working together, trying to make their work
as like each other's as possible.
Sophie had been looking forward to seeing her parents. But
what if they knew William was in Ouray? The last Sophie
had heard, William and Amy had moved away.