Anna, what a great topic. I was just writing something about making my hero suffer and how satisfying it is, then I come here and read your post! In Gideon you've got a tremendous TH. Apart from being tortured and honorable he's just so sighworthy! One of your best. I'm looking forward to rereading 'Captive of Sin'. Some of my fave THs have already been mentioned: Matthew from 'Untouched' and Jervaulx from 'Flowers in the Storm'.