Prologue
For me, it has always been a challenge to give a gift of
distinction, a gift whose relevance and usefulness far
outlasts the occasion, but today was different. Today I had
wrapped my gift with ribbons I hoped would be forever tied
to my father's heart. He had reached a major milestone in
his life that deserved to be commemorated—it was his
ninetieth birthday. My thoughts danced with anticipation,
knowing that I would be sharing this experience with him. I
planned to take him on a special outing—one I imagined
would be a passage through time for both of us.
We sat in silence as the ferry glided across the Hudson
River. Memories flooded my mind of this man who lived every
day of his life with such passion. I allowed myself the
opportunity to appreciate his presence, to reflect on my
father, to see life through his eyes. I was filled with
admiration for all he had accomplished and for all the
wisdom he possessed; not the wisdom attained by academics,
but the wisdom that can only be acquired by living a lifetime.
We arrived early that October morning—I wanted to
spend the whole day. Ellis Island had recently reopened its
doors to visitors after many years of eerie silence. A
tribute to generations of human spirit had been
memorialized, and its interior exploded with thousands of
personal stories of hardship and hope. Slowly, we wandered
through each room, absorbing all that was presented. As I
scanned the multitude of haunting faces that lined the
walls, I realized my father's could have been any one of the
forlorn expressions that mirrored the disquietude of an era.
I tried to comprehend the magnitude of their struggle and
courage, so unlike the life I had been living, but it must
have been too real for my father, his silence was
unsettling. Maybe the memories were too painful for him;
maybe too many years had passed and he could not
remember; maybe he did not want to remember.
The morning drifted by, awakening a plethora of emotions
within me, but my father looked weary, and I suggested we
take a break. Outside, in the crisp autumn air, we rested on
a bench overlooking the river—the welcomed warmth of
the sun somewhat melting the chilling reality we had just
beheld.
To ease the silence, I commented on the weather, saying,
"It's a beautiful day."
My father simply replied, "Clare, every day you're alive
is a beautiful day."
Throughout his life, the phrase "it's a beautiful day"
had become his mantra. I had always thought of it as cordial
chitchat used to fill the uncomfortable gaps of silence in
conversations, but only now did I comprehend the depth of
his penetrating words. As if I had been sleepwalking through
my years, my eyes opened wider, and I sat up straighter. His
profound statement made me realize I do not respect the
fragility of each day, the simplest pleasures in life, every
precious moment. Life is a gift, and every day is an
opportunity to revel in its glory.
As though seeing it for the first time, my father,
Vincenzo Montanaro, stared transfixed at the Statue of
Liberty that stood magnificently before us, her presence so
significant, his expression just as compelling. Witnessing
the depth of emotion so apparent on his face, my curiosity
had piqued. I wished I could snuggle inside his thoughts and
mimeograph his memories. There were many questions about his
journey to America and our family, but I wondered if he was
willing or able to fill in the pieces of the puzzle that
made up their lives. He was the sole surviving member and
the only one who could escort me across the bridge to their
past. Tenderly, I gazed into his eyes and asked him what he
remembered.
Suddenly, on this still day, a gust of wind swirled
around us, rustling the leaves on the trees, and an
unexpected chill permeated the air. Had I not known better,
I would have thought
that the ghosts of the past had just descended upon him
to refuel his mind. Gently, he took my hand in his—its
size dwarfed mine. Shaking his head insistently, he chuckled
and said he remembered it all as if it were yesterday. He
exclaimed it was befitting to start his story at the very
beginning—the one he had read in his mother's journal
revealing the circumstances that forced her to leave Italy
and escape to America. When he said his mother's name,
Victoria, it was as if he were uttering a synonym for a
saint. His eyes stared mysteriously into the distance; his
mind focused on the past; his words echoed another time,
another place, as he recalled the details with colorful
lucidity, and I unconsciously slipped into an unfamiliar
world and envisioned I was there.
Chapter 1
Caivano, Italy, 1906
Dusk refused to abate the heat of the day filtering in
with Alfredo as he lumbered through the door. The usual
carafe of wine on the table would allay his aches for the
night, but as Angelina added ingredients to the simmering
pot, she wished there was one that could numb the wound she
was about to inflict.
She waited for her husband to drain his glass and pour
himself another. He smiled weakly at her from his chair at
the table. Tonight he seemed especially tired. By now he was
usually sharing the events of his day.
Removing his spectacles, he sluggishly rubbed his eyes
with the tips of his fingers. "Dinner smells good," he said.
Angelina turned her head to look at him and forced a
smile. "It'll be a few more minutes," she said, wondering
whether she should tell him now or wait until after they
ate. Pulling the handkerchief from the sleeve of her blouse,
she blotted the beads of sweat from her forehead. Her nerves
were getting the best of her, and she felt the spoon in her
hand shaking. It had to be done now, she decided. "How was
your day?" she asked. At least it was a start.
He frowned. "One of our mares fell ill, and I had to put
her down. She was one of our best, too," he said, scratching
the bald spot on the top of his head.
Angelina instantly regretted she had asked, knowing she
was about to make his bad day worse. Hopefully, the wine had
soothed him somewhat. Walking over to the table, she wiped
her palms on her apron. "Alfredo, I have something very
difficult to tell you. I want you to know that I thought
long and hard about this, and I believe it was the right
thing to do."
"Then why do you sound so unconvinced?" He lifted his
eyebrows and raised his hand
along with the question.
She held on to the back of a chair for support and looked
down at the table to avert his gaze. Her heart was pounding
hard inside her chest, and she took a few deep breaths,
trying to calm down. "There's no easy way to tell you this,"
she finally said.
"What is it, Angelina?" he said, heaving a sigh of slight
impatience.
"I gave Victoria our savings so she could go to America
and be with Dominick. She'll be safe with her brother. He'll
take care of them." As she spoke she saw her husband's face
twist into a knot of disbelief and rage, and panic descended
upon her like darkness on a moonless night. "She was
miserable. She was so unhappy...and the children. Believe
me, Alfredo, it's the only way they could get away from him."
Slamming his hand to his chest, he demanded, "Where are
they?"
"They left before dawn."
"Tell me this isn't true!" His voice grew louder, and his
skin flushed crimson. "What were you thinking? You should've
come to me!" His bulging eyes bore into her. "Damn it,
Angelina! Didn't you think how this would affect all of us?"
Overwhelmed by her own guilt and loss, Angelina had no
reply and looked away.
Jumping to his feet, Alfredo bounded over to the mattress
and threw up its corner, exposing the empty spot where their
coins had been hidden. Spinning around, he shoved her with
both hands, and she caught the bottom of her skirt with the
heel of her boot as she stumbled backward. Regaining her
footing, she stood rigid and took a slow, ragged breath. She
realized her betrayal had warranted his harsh reaction, but
the words that followed struck her harder.
"How could you have disrespected me this way? What's
wrong with you? I've lost my family! I've lost everything!"
Glaring down at the floor, he brusquely paced back and
forth. "My
God, there's nothing left," he added with an abandon
Angelina had never heard before.
"Please, don't say that," she pleaded, her body quivering
along with her voice. "Someday they'll come back, or maybe
we'll go there."
"What are the chances of that? Don't you understand,
woman, we'll never see them again! How can I ever forgive
you for this?"
Angelina clasped her hands over her ears, attempting to
shut out his irrefutable words, his consummate anger.
Alfredo collapsed onto the edge of their bed. He sat
hunched over and covered his face with his hands, catching
the tears that poured from his heart, and his agony
mercilessly pierced Angelina to the core.
Chapter 2
Six years earlier, 1900
The sweet nectar of ripened grapes drifted through the
air as Victoria walked through the vineyards toward the
river with a basket of clothes balanced upon her head. A
disarming inquisitiveness stirred inside her when she caught
a glimpse of Salvatore's thick, dark hair and smooth, olive
skin glistening in the afternoon sun. The muscles on his
arms and back flexed as he heaved the heavy logs onto a cart.
Victoria knew little about the boy she was admiring and
found herself wondering why words had never passed between
them. Salvatore lived on the outskirts of the village, and
she was aware his family worked the lumber mill. It was
rumored that his mother had taken her own life many years
ago, but Victoria did not pay it much heed until now.
Watching him, she suddenly felt a twinge of compassion and
decided to question her father that evening.
Relaxing at the end of the day, Papa and her brother,
Dominick, sat at the table sipping wine, while Mama juggled
the well–worn pots and utensils that hung like a frame
around the hearth's perimeter. Victoria and her
sister–in–law, Genevieve, watched Angelina tend
to the blackened cauldron suspended above the flames. The
fragrant aroma of its contents mingled with the air,
tantalizing Victoria with an assortment of the earth's
finest treasures. She could feel the golden warmth sautéing
in her stomach—a fusion of flavors garnished with her
mother's tenderness.
Placing bowls on the table, Victoria nonchalantly asked,
"Papa, what happened to Salvatore Ricci's mother?"
Alfredo looked up at her. The autumn air was warm and
still, and he swiped the sweat from his brow with the back
of his hand. "Life is more difficult for some than for
others, my child," he finally said.
His abbreviated explanation did not appease Victoria.
"What do you mean? Tell me, I want to know."
"It's complicated. Let's just say a good woman left us
before the Lord was ready for her."
"Wasn't she married to your cousin Francis?" she asked.
"Francis is my second cousin, but we no longer speak of
him in this house."
Angelina turned from the hearth to face her husband.
"Alfredo, maybe it's time you told them what happened with
Francis."
Victoria glanced at her brother curiously, and he
shrugged his shoulders, looking just as confused.
Alfredo bent over and struck a match on the wood floor
and lit his pipe. "Francis and I haven't spoken for years.
He thought his personal life was none of my concern, and he
reacted with fists rather than words." He took a drag on his
pipe and watched the smoke as he exhaled. "You have to
understand, Francis is as hard as the wood he mills. With a
heavy hand, he sends his children home each evening covered
in sawdust and craving a sliver of praise or affection." He
paused. "The sad truth is that Josephina took her own life
to escape the severity of the husband who broke her spirit,
leaving behind her six children." His voice was soft, and he
shook his head as he spoke. "It was a sad day indeed, not
only for her family, but for much of the village. There are
some that still look down upon her for what she did. I say
only God can judge us."
Genevieve walked over to Dominick. He slipped his arm
around her waist and pulled her close as Victoria muttered
grimly, "How awful."
Eyeing Victoria, Alfredo asked, "Why this sudden interest?"
"I saw Salvatore working at the mill today, and I was
just wondering..."
In a firm tone, Alfredo insisted, "Victoria, I want you
to stay away from him."
She was taken aback by his curt reply. "Why?"
With his elbow resting on the arm of his chair, he
pointed his finger in the air as he spoke. "Although I have
pity for him, his childhood has been filled with the kind of
grief that stirs the soul and torments the mind."
Standing at the opposite end of the table, Victoria
opined, "But, Papa, maybe he could use a friend."
"Then let him look elsewhere for his friends."
She straightened her back. "That's unkind. I'm fourteen
and—"
"And nothing! Salvatore is a man at eighteen, and you're
merely a child."
Unnerved to think her father still considered her a
child, Victoria's eyes grew wide as she swallowed the judgment.
Turning to his son, Alfredo asked, "Did you finish
loading the barrels so everything's ready for the morning?"
"It's all done," Dominick said.
Victoria slumped into her chair with her eyes still wide
on her father and her frustration festering inside, and
dinner began in an awkward silence.
Now it made sense to Victoria why Salvatore's family kept
to themselves. She thought that it was unfair the children
had been left without a mother and were living with a father who
was so cruel. She was surprised her father was so
insensitive. His disagreement with Francis should have no
reflection on his children. Her father claimed that God was
the only judge, but Alfredo had already judged Salvatore
without even giving him a chance.
Victoria had lost her appetite but forced herself to eat.
Her stomach felt queasy, and she declined the ladleful of
stewed pears her mother offered for dessert. She wondered if
Salvatore was having dessert, she wondered who cooked him
his meals.
When everyone had finished, she and Genevieve cleared the
plates while Angelina filled the basin with the kettle of
warm water that was hanging above the hearth. It was
Victoria's turn to wash, and Genevieve picked up the towel
to dry.
"That's so sad what Papa just told us," Victoria said to
Genevieve, keeping her voice low.
"Francis must be a horrible man. I feel sorry for his
children," Genevieve said.
Victoria turned around to look at her mother. "Did you
know Josephine?" she asked.
"Not that well. She was a quiet woman...kept to herself.
It was heartbreaking what happened." Angelina sighed. "I'll
never forget the look on her children's faces when she was
laid to rest. It was all so sad." She took the dried pot
from Genevieve, hung it on a hook by the fire, and turned
back around. "Papa didn't want to go to her funeral because
of Francis, but I told him that he should out of respect for
Josephine." They worked together in silence until Angelina
put the last of the cleaned dishes on the shelf and broke
the lull. "Let's sit down now," she said.
Alfredo removed the Bible from the sideboard near the
cottage's entrance. It was their most treasured possession.
It guided their family with lessons of faith, and he taught
Victoria and Dominick how to read and write its sacred
words. Gently carrying it in the palms of his hands, he
placed it on the table and sat down. He carefully opened the
book—its edges frayed and pages brittle—and
started his story in an animated flare. "The sun beat down
on the thousands upon
thousands of people in the desert who were starving, and
they begged Jesus for help. He told his disciples to gather
food, and he took the five loaves of bread and two fish and
asked God for a miracle. He ordered his disciples to feed
the masses, and everyone sat and ate their meal in awe until
their stomachs were filled and..." As Alfredo spoke, he
twisted the stiff hairs of his arched mustache with his
fingers as if conjuring the scene. In the glow of the
candlelight, his weathered skin was thick and creased, and
his round, blue eyes were encircled with wisdom.
Normally, Victoria absorbed his every word, the
conviction of his tone, and the resoluteness of his
expression. Tonight, however, she was having trouble
concentrating on her father's voice. For the first time, she
was listening to the beat of her own heart.
When Alfredo ended the parable, he made the sign of the
cross before closing the book. "Tomorrow's going to be a
long day, and we should all get our rest."
Victoria was the one to always pout a protest and plead
for more, but this evening she was relieved to be alone with
her thoughts.
"Genevieve and I will be back at sun up," Dominick said
to his father as he rose from the table. "Good night, Mama.
Dinner was delicious." Angelina held out her cheek, and
Dominick affectionately planted a kiss next to the smile on
her face. "Good night, sis," he called out.
"See you in the morning," Genevieve said. Following her
husband out the door, she gave Victoria a sympathetic smile
and her eyes flashed concern.
Victoria felt a sudden rush of gratitude. Genevieve had
sensed her interest in Salvatore was more than a passing
breeze; of that she was certain. Her
sister–in–law had grown up just over the hill,
and she was Victoria's best friend prior to becoming
Dominick's wife. Over the years, she and Genevieve had
developed a silent language only they had the power to discern.
Yawning, Victoria blew a kiss in her parents' direction
and mumbled a weak, "Good night." She climbed the ladder to
the loft and quickly changed into her nightdress. Lying down
on the feathered mattress, she haphazardly covered herself
with a quilt—so worn, the designs of her
great–grandmother had long since faded—and
turned on her side. Alfredo blew out the last of the candles
dotting the cottage's interior, causing darkness to descend.
Below, her parents' bed rested on a timbered frame as
intricately molded as the people it lulled, while Victoria
lay wide–eyed above them, eager for the morning to
come, eager to see Salvatore again.